Elden Ring stands out not only for its immersive world and intricate lore but also for its exceptional replay value. One of the biggest reasons many players return to the Lands Between for a second, third, or even tenth journey is the vast variety of items—many of which can drastically change how you approach the game.
As someone who has completed multiple playthroughs, I’ve come to appreciate how each item isn’t just a tool—it’s a path. Whether you’re chasing a different ending, experimenting with a new build, or diving deeper into the lore, these 10 items are a big part of what makes replaying Elden Ring so rewarding.
And for those looking to experiment without spending dozens of hours grinding, the Best site to buy Elden Ring Items and the Best Place to buy Elden Ring Runes—such as U4GM—can help you get straight to the fun part: discovering what makes each item (and each build) unique.
1. Moonveil Katana
This weapon redefines magic/melee hybrid play. With its intelligence scaling and devastating weapon art, it creates an entirely different experience from a typical strength build. It became my go-to weapon in NG+, and it never got old watching enemies fall from a well-timed Transient Moonlight slash.
2. Rivers of Blood
Another weapon that completely shifts your gameplay. Bleed builds are fast-paced and satisfying, especially in PvP. When I first tried Rivers of Blood, it felt like I was playing a completely different game—one that thrived on aggression.
3. Radagon’s Scarseal/Sourceal
These talismans are risky but rewarding. They push you to play more carefully by increasing damage taken while enhancing your offensive power. They taught me a lot about discipline and decision-making under pressure, especially during boss fights.
4. Comet Azur
The ultimate glass cannon spell. Using this sorcery turns you into a long-range powerhouse—but only if you’re willing to manage positioning and casting time. On my second sorcery-focused character, this spell made me feel powerful in a whole new way.
5. Mimic Tear Ashes
Summoning your own clone changes how you engage with enemies. The AI fights exactly as you do, which means your build influences the summon’s effectiveness. I found this to be a game-changer during my NG+ boss runs—it felt like tag-teaming with a skilled co-op partner.
6. Bloodhound’s Step
This Ash of War offers an evasive playstyle that can make certain fights feel entirely different. Instead of blocking or rolling, you dart around like a phantom. It reinvigorated my love for agility-based builds and gave me an edge in difficult encounters.
7. Greatshield Talisman
Perfect for tank builds, this item turns shield blocking into a near-impenetrable defense. On my fourth playthrough, I focused on a pure tank using this talisman—and it felt like a completely fresh way to enjoy the game.
8. Blasphemous Blade
A high-damage, life-stealing weapon tied to one of the most interesting lore arcs in the game. This weapon gave me the motivation to explore more Faith-based builds and follow Rykard’s story more closely in a later playthrough.
9. Sacred Relic Sword
This weapon is only available after finishing the game, and it’s an excellent reason to dive into New Game+. Its wave-attack weapon skill clears mobs efficiently and makes farming easier. I used it in NG+ to quickly gather runes and experiment with higher-level builds.
For fast-tracking those builds, I relied on U4GM, long considered the Best Place to buy Elden Ring Runes, to avoid excessive grinding and enjoy the diversity the game offers.
10. Tonic of Forgetfulness
A story item with optional consequences, this one’s less about mechanics and more about choice. You might miss it in your first run, but it unlocks a morally complex option with one of the game’s most mysterious characters. Discovering it in a later playthrough made me reflect on how flexible Elden Ring’s storytelling truly is.
Elden Ring’s replayability isn’t just due to its vast world—it’s driven by items that unlock new styles, tactics, and stories. These ten items are just a glimpse of what makes returning to the game such a rich experience.
And if you’re planning another playthrough or looking to test new builds without the time sink, services like U4GM—trusted as the Best site to buy Elden Ring Items and the Best Place to buy Elden Ring Runes—can make it easier to focus on what really matters: exploration, experimentation, and discovering new layers of this unforgettable game.